Integrating sources

Integrating supporting evidence and information into your work is an important part of academic communication. This adds credibility by demonstrating your understanding of the existing literature and relevant research. It also reinforces the validity of your claims and allows readers to trace the origins of the information presented. Importantly, it gives credit to the intellectual contributions of others and shows respect for their work.

In brief, there are several things to keep in mind when citing:

  • Different citation structures when citing information within a paragraph, depending on whether you want to place the focus on the author or the ideas.
  • Taking notes in your own words rather than copying the text helps avoid plagiarism.
  • Paraphrasing is writing someone else’s ideas into your own words.
  • Summarising distils the essence of a passage into a shorter version.
  • Synthesising combines similar findings amongst two or more sources.
  • Quoting involves directly incorporating the exact words of an author into your work.

Citing correctly

Citing is the practice of giving credit when you include the ideas, research or data communicated by others in your work. Citations typically include details such as the author’s name and publication year and should be written following the rules of a specific referencing style.

In-text citations are the part of referencing where you give credit within your work, acknowledging theories, data or information as you present them. Every source cited in your work needs a corresponding entry in your reference list. The reference list is placed at the end of your work and provides more information about your cited sources, enabling the reader to connect to them. For more information on the formatting of citations and references, view our referencing guides.

There are several ways to structure your citations:

Information prominent

Information prominent citations focus on the ideas or theories you are communicating. In these citations, the author’s surname and year of publication (and sometimes page number) are in brackets following the evidence you present.

Example

AI literacy is frequently defined as a “set of competencies that enables individuals to critically evaluate AI technologies, communicate and collaborate effectively with AI, and use AI as a tool online, at home and in the workplace” (Long & Magerko, 2022, p. 2).

Author prominent

Author-prominent citations emphasise the author, which can be useful, for example, if you want to highlight them as an expert in the field or provide a longer summary of their work. In this form, the author’s name is included within the sentence, with the year (and sometimes page number) appearing in brackets directly after.

Example

On the resilience of people in the face of technological change, Sam Altman (2023), CEO of OpenAI, said on social media, “the turing [sic] test went whooshing by and everyone mostly went about their lives”.

Secondary citations

Sometimes, you may want to cite an author you have read about in someone else’s work. It can be difficult to determine whether you need to give credit to the original author (also known as the primary author) or the author of the source you are reading.

Generally, the original author should be cited when quoted, or their findings are discussed in detail in the source you are referring to, particularly if you want to reproduce those findings in your assessment.

It is unnecessary to cite the original author when their work is only used briefly to support the secondary author’s argument.

Example

The prevalence of AI technology is still unknown to many people; in a recent poll, “37% of respondents said they had used an AI tool. [However] of those who said they had not used AI tools, 63% actually had” (HubSpot, 2016, as cited in Bashir, 2022, p. 26).

Referencing styles

There are different rules for how citations should be presented, depending on the referencing style required by your unit. For instructions on creating an in-text citation in APA, Chicago, AGLC, IEEE or Vancouver, see the Curtin Library’s referencing guides.

Plagiarism explained

Plagiarism happens when you use the work of others but present it as your own. Very few people deliberately choose to plagiarise. Instead, it occurs when referencing is overlooked or when there is very little difference between a source’s words, phrasing and structure and your assessment.

The best way to avoid accidental plagiarism is to take care during the note-taking phase of the writing process. Take notes in your own words rather than copying phrases directly, and note down the details of the information source alongside the relevant notes. That way, when you include the ideas in your assessment, you will know which source to cite.

Paraphrasing

Paraphrasing is writing someone else’s ideas into your own words. It involves rephrasing information from a source while maintaining the original meaning. It is not simply about replacing a few words with synonyms – you need to understand the core concepts and restructure the information to reflect your understanding. By paraphrasing, you demonstrate your ability to seamlessly incorporate ideas and evidence into your writing, showcasing your understanding of the subject matter and your unique voice.

Paraphrase example

Original

“The world must ensure that new technologies, especially those based on AI, are used for the good of our societies and their sustainable development. It should regulate AI developments and applications so that they conform to the fundamental rights that frame our democratic horizon” (Azoulay, 2018).

Paraphrased

New AI developments should be regulated so that their use adheres to fundamental human rights and any impact on communities globally is beneficial and sustainable (Azoulay, 2018).

  1. Identify the content you want to paraphrase. If your selected excerpt/passage exceeds four sentences, jump to the summarising section.
  2. Re-read the content/excerpt and identify the most important concepts or key words. This is the information that must be included in your paraphrase to ensure that the meaning isn’t changed as you rewrite it. In our example, the key concepts are new technologies, societal good, sustainable development, AI regulation, and fundamental rights.
  3. Cross out any words, information or examples that aren’t necessary or can be grouped into a larger category. In our example, “new technologies, especially those based on AI” can be combined into “new AI developments”.
  4. Note the order that these concepts and words are presented in within the original passage. In the original example, the order of information is: new technology, societal good and sustainable development, regulation, then fundamental rights.
  5. Cover the original passage and rephrase the content by reorganising the structure, replacing words, and reducing overall length.
  6. Compare with the original passage to ensure that you have not copied the source material.
  7. Insert your citation in the appropriate position. If your paraphrase consists of more than one sentence, ensure that you have introduced the first sentence with an author-prominent citation and placed an information-prominent citation at the end of the second.

  • Understand the material: Before paraphrasing, make sure you fully understand the original text. Break down complex ideas into key points and concepts.
  • Take notes first: Jot down the main ideas from the source material in your own words. This will help you internalise the information and make it easier to paraphrase later.
  • Use your own words: Avoid directly copying sentences. Instead, rephrase the content while preserving the original meaning. You may like to replace words with synonyms and reorganise sentence structures. Be mindful of the context to ensure accuracy.
  • Acknowledge the source: Use correct citation methods to show the source of the information. See above for information on how to cite correctly.
  • Compare your paraphrase with the original: Ensure you haven’t inadvertently retained too much of the original wording or structure. Check that your paraphrase begins differently than the original source and that the information is presented in a different order.

Top tip! If you’re having difficulty paraphrasing, imagine telling someone else about the passage. What are the main points they would need to know to understand it?

Summarising

Unlike paraphrasing, which rephrases information in your own words, summarising distils the essence of a passage into a shorter version. In academic writing, it involves capturing the key points and main ideas of a text while omitting unnecessary details. A well-crafted summary demonstrates your understanding of the material and allows you to convey complex information to your audience efficiently.

You can summarise a whole text, a section of it, or a paragraph. However long your summary is, it should not be a full recap or synopsis of the information, or simply a description of what happened; you are conveying only the main ideas from the original source. This means you should leave out supporting ideas and examples.

Summary example

Original

“AI is important for its potential to change how we live, work and play. It has been effectively used in business to automate tasks done by humans, including customer service work, lead generation, fraud detection and quality control. In a number of areas, AI can perform tasks much better than humans. Particularly when it comes to repetitive, detail-oriented tasks, such as analyzing large numbers of legal documents to ensure relevant fields are filled in properly, AI tools often complete jobs quickly and with relatively few errors.” (Lackowski, 2023).

Single-sentence summary

Lackowski (2023) states that there are areas where AI technology is out-performing humans, leading to more efficient and accurate completion of tasks.

Multi-sentence summary

Lackowski (2023) notes that the efficiency and accuracy of AI technology means the tools can out-perform humans on repetitive or detail-oriented tasks. The increasing automation of tasks previously done by humans will create changes in both personal and professional lives (Lackowski, 2023).

  1. Identify the content that you want to summarise and re-read it thoroughly to make sure you understand it.
  2. Break the passage into sections to make it more manageable. Most research articles will be structured around a series of sub-themes.
  3. Highlight the most important information and make notes in your own words. When reading for an assessment on a particular topic, the key information may be the information that is most relevant to your needs.
  4. Remove examples and supporting ideas. When summarising, the goal is to find the essential points, so leave out anything that can be considered supplementary.
  5. Begin writing your summary using only your notes. If you are stuck on what to include, hide your notes and attempt to recount the original content without looking at the source.
  6. Compare your summary to your notes and the original source. Have you used your own words while keeping the original meaning? Is your summary simply describing the original piece? If it is just a description, try again and see what details you can exclude.

  • Understand the text: Before attempting to summarise, ensure you thoroughly understand the original text. Identify the main ideas, key arguments, and supporting evidence. If you don’t understand a word, use a dictionary or Gen-AI to learn what they mean. Avoid trying to guess the meanings.
  • Take notes first: Jot down the main ideas from the source material in your own words. This will help you internalise the information and make it easier to write the summary later.
  • Use your own words: Avoid directly copying sentences. Instead, rephrase the content while preserving the original meaning. Imagine telling someone else about the passage. What are the main points they would need to know to understand it?
  • Be selective: Summarising involves condensing information, so omit unnecessary or minor details and examples.
  • Maintain logical flow: Organise the summarised information in a logical order, ensuring that the main ideas follow a coherent structure.
  • Acknowledge the original source: Use correct citation methods to show the source of the information. See above for information on See above for information on how to cite correctly.

Top tip!

If you’re having difficulties summarising, try reading the passage once before covering it up. Then, attempt to recap what you just read without looking at it. By doing this, it’s more likely that you’ll focus on the key information rather than any minor details.

Synthesising

Unlike paraphrasing and summarising, which use only one source’s idea at a time, a synthesis combines similar findings amongst two or more sources, allowing you to demonstrate links between different authors. Synthesis requires you to analyse, interpret and combine information to generate new insights or perspectives. This process fosters a deeper understanding of the subject matter and allows you to present a nuanced and comprehensive view.

Synthesis example

Algorithmic bias due to unrepresentative training data has been researched widely in healthcare, with findings demonstrating that lack of data diversity has caused consistent underdiagnoses, lack of contextual consideration, and improper or incorrect treatment recommendations (Byrne, 2021; Seyyed-Kalantari, 2021; Weissglass, 2022). However, clinical tests that account for racial and ethnic differences have proven successful (Noseworthy et al. 2020), highlighting the importance of consistent human oversight and use of diverse data sets.

Paragraph theme: Algorithmic bias

  • First: List of findings from similar studies
  • Second: Alternate, supporting findings

  1. Identify the theme of your paragraph or the claim you want to support with evidence.
  2. Referring to your notes, highlight information related to the theme you are trying to support, including contrary or disagreeing information.
  3. Restructure and/or group your selected information into sub-themes or concepts. For example, agrees vs disagrees, affects one group vs affects another, etc. You can do this by colour coding or numbering.
  4. Write your synthesis, paraphrasing or summarising the information from the sources. Make use of transition phrases and linking words.

  • Read and analyse sources carefully: Identify key arguments, evidence, and the author’s main points. It is also important to consider what the authors haven’t covered.
  • Ensure you take notes on your sources: It’s much easier to synthesise information after unpacking and annotating the information you’re working with. Including page numbers will help if you need to return to the original source later.
  • Highlight relationships between sources: This could involve comparing viewpoints, demonstrating how one source builds upon another or highlighting complementary perspectives.
  • Organise your thoughts: Create an outline or mind map to organise the information from various sources. This visual representation can help you see connections and develop your own perspective.
  • Maintain a balanced tone: Acknowledge conflicting viewpoints and demonstrate an awareness of the complexities within the topic.
  • Acknowledge the sources: Use correct citation methods to show the source of the information. See above for information on See above for information on how to cite correctly.

Quoting

Quoting involves directly incorporating the exact words of an author into your work. Quotes are used to support your arguments, provide evidence or showcase an expert’s opinion. Use quotations when the author expresses something in a way that significantly strengthens your point or idea, uses a particularly striking or memorable phrase, or their authority in the field lends itself to using their exact words.

Always use quotation marks to denote the exact words from the source and include the author’s name, publication year and page number to provide proper citation.

Tips for quoting effectively

  • Choose quotes wisely: Select quotes that are relevant, impactful, and directly support your argument. Using too many quotes will drown your own voice. A good rule of thumb is to keep quotations under 5% of the total words.
  • Maintain context: Provide sufficient context before and after the quote to help readers understand its relevance and how it fits into your overall argument.
  • Integrate quotes smoothly: Avoid abrupt transitions by incorporating the quoted material into your sentence structure. Attributing the quote to the author can help integrate it into the flow of your writing (e.g., According to Smith, “life is good”.)
  • Add words to a quote: Do this to help it blend with the rest of your sentence, particularly if you need to change tense, help it make more sense or make something more concise. Record your words in square brackets.
    • Original quote: “The program is utterly indifferent to the truth or falsehood of its writings.” (MacKenzie, 2023, p. 9)
    • Quote with added words: “The [ChatGPT] program is utterly indifferent to the truth or falsehood of its writings.” (MacKenzie, 2023, p. 9)
  • Consider length: Be mindful of the length of your quotes. In general, shorter quotes are often more effective, allowing you to maintain control over the narrative. Quotes longer than 40 words are usually indented with quotation marks removed.
  • Use an ellipsis: An ellipsis shows that something has been left out of the original wording and that your quote differs somewhat from the source. You can leave out words that are not needed if it doesn’t change the meaning of the original statement. Note: in general, you don’t need to use an ellipsis if words are left out of the beginning or end of a quote; however, if the reader might mistake an incomplete quote for a complete one, then an ellipsis should be used.
    • Original quote: “ChatGPT became the fastest-growing online app for consumers in history, reaching one million users in the first five days after its release and 100 million in its first two months.” (MacKenzie, 2023, p. 9)
    • Quote with ellipsis: “ChatGPT became the fastest-growing online app for consumers in history, reaching … 100 million in its first two months.” (MacKenzie, 2023, p. 9)
  • Use [sic] for unconventional words, grammar or spelling: When quoting, you should use the exact words from the source, even if the author has used regionally different spelling, incorrect grammar, or an unconventional word. In these situations, include the word ‘sic’ (meaning intentionally so written) in square brackets next to the word in question. E.g., [sic].

Are you a Curtin student who would like to work through a module and gain a certificate for learning more about citing in your writing? Access the Writing with Integrity module.